Had Fred McGriff Played In The "Second Deadball Era" Rather Than The Steroid Era He'd Already Be In The Hall of Fame

Fred McGriff 1994 Upper Deck

If any player is in danger of becoming a victim of the era he played in, it's Fred McGriff.  Had he played in any other era, McGriff's 493 career home runs, 1,550 RBIs, 2,490 hits, .284 batting average, and .377 on base percentage would have earned the lanky slugger a bronze Hall of Fame plaque.  Unfortunately, "Crime Dog" played a large portion of his career in what would become known as the Steroid Era.  Thus far, the BBWAA Hall of Fame voters have not been kind to the home run hitting sluggers of the Steroid Era.  Whether they are an admitted PED user (Mark McGwire), an exposed PED user (Rafael Palmeiro), or an accused PED user (Juan Gonzalez), the voters have made it clear that players whose careers have been tarnished by accused or proven PED use won't be making the Hall of Fame anytime soon--as none of those sluggers has yet to accumulate even one quarter of the three quarters of the vote needed for election.  Jeff Bagwell, another power hitter from the Steroid Era, collected 56% of the vote on the latest Hall of Fame ballot, but Bagwell has seen many writers withhold voting for him due to suspicions and whispers about his muscular body shape.  By contrast, the writers have not had the same reservations about voting in Steroid Era second basemen with moderate power like Roberto Alomar and Barry Larkin who were elected in 2011 and 2012, on their second and third ballot, respectively.  The controversy generated by sluggers of the Steroid Era shows no signs of slowing down with accused PED users Barry Bonds and Sammy Sosa--two of the most central figures of the Steroid Era--set to join the already controversial ballot in the upcoming election.

McGriff, on the other hand, was neither accused nor even suspected of PED use, though playing in the Steroid Era with his PED using peers has not only minimized his accomplishments but has also devalued his impressive statistics.  Unfortunately, due to all the attention given to the PED using sluggers of the Steroid Era and their tarnished achievements, McGriff's Hall of Fame candidacy has become somewhat of an afterthought to most voters, as after three years on the ballot, McGriff himself has yet to eclipse 25% of the vote.  And with his vote totals likely to stagnate in the next few years due to a glut of impressive and controversial candidates set to join an already crowded ballot, McGriff obviously has a long but not insurmountable road ahead of him to be elected.  However, had he played in any other era, would McGriff have had this hard a time gaining support for his Hall of Fame candidacy?

Willie McCovey and Willie Stargell 1978 Topps

There is no way to truly know how a player would have fared had they played in another era.  It is impossible to know how factors from different eras would alter a player's performance.  Based on Baseball Reference's Similarity Scores Method originally introduced by Bill James, the sluggers with the two most similar career statistics to McGriff are Hall of Famers Willie McCovey and Willie Stargell, while another Hall of Famer's career, Billy Williams, is ranked eighth most similar to McGriff's.  McCovey, like McGriff, was a first baseman, Stargell split his career between left field and first, and Williams was a left fielder.  While McGriff played most of his career in a high scoring, hitter friendly era, McCovey, Stargell, and Williams were prominent power hitters during the low scoring 1960's and early 1970's, a time period often referred to as the "Second Deadball Era."  When directly compared to players from the same generation, who started their careers within five years of them, Stargell and McCovey stand tall, ranking third and fourth in career home runs, while Williams and McGriff check in seventh and ninth.  However, the sluggers ahead of McGriff in his own era read like a roll call sheet for accused and proven PED users.  And, if we remove those players from the list, McGriff's totals look much more impressive with the slugger moving comfortably into fourth:

Top 10 Career HRs of Players Who Started Their							Top 10 Career HRs of Players Who Started Their
Career's Between '81-'91							Career's Between '81-'91
accused and proven PED users are highlighted in red							minus accused and proven PED users
	Player	Career	HRs	OPS+	HR titles			Player	Career	HRs	OPS+	HR titles
1	Bonds	86-07	762	181	2		1	Griffey	89-10	630	136	4
2	Griffey	89-10	630	136	4		2	Thome	91-**	604	147	1
3	Sosa	89-07	609	128	2		3	Thomas	90-08	521	156	0
4	Thome	91-**	604	147	1		4	McGriff	86-04	493	134	2
5	McGwire	86-01	583	163	4		5	Bagwell	91-05	449	149	0
6	Palmeiro	86-05	569	132	0		6	Galarraga	85-04	399	119	1
7	Thomas	90-08	521	156	0		7	Walker	89-05	383	141	1
8	Sheffield	88-09	509	140	0		8	Belle	89-00	381	144	1
9	McGriff	86-04	493	134	2		9	Gaetti	81-00	360	97	0
10	Canseco	85-01	462	132	2		10	G Vaughn	89-03	355	113	0
**Thome's stats through 2011							**Thome's stats through 2011
Top 10 Career HRs of Players Who Started Their							Top 10 Career HRs of Players Who Started Their
Career's Between '54-'64							Career's Between '57-'67
	Player	Career	HRs	OPS+	HR titles			Player	Career	HRs	OPS+	HR titles
1	Aaron	54-76	755	155	4		1	R Jackson	67-87	563	139	4
2	Robinson	56-76	586	154	1		2	McCovey	59-80	521	147	3
3	Killebrew	54-75	573	143	6		3	Stargell	62-82	475	147	2
4	McCovey	59-80	521	147	3		4	Yaz	61-83	452	130	1
5	Stargell	62-82	475	147	2		5	Williams	59-76	426	133	0
6	Yaz	61-83	452	130	1		6	Nettles*	67-88	390	110	1
7	Williams	59-76	426	133	0		7	Bench	67-83	389	126	2
8	Howard*	58-73	382	142	2		8	Howard*	58-73	382	142	2
9	Cepeda	58-74	379	133	1		9	Cepeda	58-74	379	133	1
9	Perez	64-86	379	122	0		10	Perez	64-86	379	122	0
*Frank Howard is only non-HOFer among top 10							*Nettles & Howard are only non-HOFers among top 10

Baseball Reference also has another interesting tool called Neutralized Batting which measures how a player's career statistics would look if you convert their stats into a certain year, league, and home ballpark.  When McGriff's 1986-2004 career is placed into McCovey's 1959-1980* ('59-'77 for McGriff since he played 19 seasons versus McCovey's 22) career span with McCovey's home ballparks, McGriff's totals decrease in every counting stat except for games and hits since he would not have lost nearly half a season's worth of games due to the 1994-1995 strike:

	G	R	H	HR	RBI	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS
McCovey	2588	1229	2211	521	1555	0.270	0.374	0.515	0.889
McGriff	2505	1257	2393	478	1440	0.273	0.363	0.490	0.853
*McGriff 59-77: 59 Seals Stadium, 60-73, 77 Candlestick, 74-76 San Diego Stadium

When you put McGriff's career into Stargell's '62-'82* span, you actually get almost the same results as you do with McCovey:

	G	R	H	HR	RBI	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS
Stargell	2360	1195	2232	475	1540	0.282	0.360	0.529	0.889
McGriff	2517	1252	2396	477	1436	0.272	0.362	0.488	0.850
*McGriff 62-80: 62-69 Forbes Field, 70 Forbes/3 Rivers, 71-80 Three Rivers Stadium

However, when you do the same thing with Williams' '59-'76* career, McGriff takes less of a hit since he would benefit from playing his home games at Wrigley Field--a notorious hitter's park where Williams hit 231 of his 426 career home runs--and finishes with almost the exact same career numbers as he did in his actual '86-'04 career:

	G	R	H	HR	RBI	BA	OBP	SLG	OPS
Williams	2488	1410	2711	426	1475	0.290	0.361	0.492	0.853
McGriff	2505	1326	2481	493	1525	0.280	0.371	0.502	0.873
*McGriff 59-77: 59-74 Wrigley Field, 75-77 Oakland Coliseum
McGriff^	2460	1349	2490	493	1550	0.284	0.377	0.509	0.886
^Actual McGriff 86-04 career totals

Billy Williams 1964 Topps

McCovey and Stargell, both winners of a NL MVP trophy and owners of a 147 career OPS+, were more dominant sluggers than McGriff and Williams whose OPS+ were 134 and 133, respectively.  Although their careers were a little shorter in length than McCovey and Stargell's, McGriff and Williams' were noteworthy for their durability.  McGriff played 150 or more games in a season ten times and 140 or more three times--not counting the strike shortened '94 and '95 seasons where he was on pace to play over 150 games, while Williams reached 150 games in thirteen seasons and 140 in one other.  By contrast, McCovey only reached 150 games four times and 140 three times, while Stargell never had a season in which he played 150 games and just six where he reached 140.  Both McCovey and Stargell courageously battled back from their injuries time and time again, allowing them to have long careers and earn them the milestones that helped make them first ballot Hall of Famers.  However, McCovey and Stargell's recurring injuries forced their teams to play a replacement level player such as Gary Thomasson or Jose Pagan in place of their ailing star.  Conversely, McGriff didn't spend a day on the disabled list until his last full season in 2003, while from 1963 to 1970 Williams played in 1,117 consecutive games, the sixth longest such streak in MLB history.

Some writers and fans have inaccurately labeled McGriff as a "compiler" and say that the slender slugger owes his impressive career numbers to longevity rather than excellence.  Others say his stats don't quite measure up in the era he played.  McGriff's career stats are a byproduct of consistency, durability, and excellence--not just longevity.  There are few players in baseball history as consistent as McGriff, who for 16-straight seasons, from 1987 to 2002, hit no less than 19 home runs and in 10 of those seasons hit 30 or more.  In contrast to sluggers like McCovey and Stargell, "Crime Dog" could be counted on for his durability.  In fact, McGriff ranks third all-time with 2,239 games played at first.  As far as excellence goes, from 1988 to 1994, McGriff averaged 35 home runs, 95 RBIs, a .288 batting average, .390 OBP, and 155 OPS+.  Moreover, during that seven year span, McGriff won three Silver Slugger Awards, finished in the top 4 in homers each year in his respective league--leading the AL in 1989 and NL in 1992--and led all of baseball with 242 homers.

Top 5 HRs 1988 to 1994					Top 5 HRs 1995 to 2002
	Player	HRs	OPS+			Player	HRs	OPS+
1	McGriff	242	155		1	Sosa	404	148
2	Bonds	218	170		2	Bonds	354	197
3	Carter	213	111		3	McGwire	345	183
4	Canseco	207	148		4	Palmeiro	335	140
5	Fielder	197	130		5	Thome	304	159

Fred McGriff 2000 Fleer Tradition

While it is true that McGriff did benefit from playing the latter half of his career in a hitter friendly post-expansion era with smaller ballparks, he also faced his share of PED using starting pitchers, middle relievers, set up men, and closers so if he wasn't taking the chemical shortcuts that so many of his peers were then he wouldn't have gained much of an advantage.  Also, most of McGriff's career peak came in the pitcher friendly time period before the 1993 expansion draft that ushered in the dawn of the hitter's era which evolved into the Steroid Era.  And, while he was no longer able to dominate as he had before the Steroid Era, McGriff remained one of baseball's most consistent and durable players, averaging 27 home runs, 99 RBIs, a .288 batting average, .371 OBP, and 122 OPS+ from 1995 to 2002, while still playing an average of 150 games.

Had McGriff played in the "Second Deadball Era" in McCovey, Stargell, or Williams' career span, he would have retired after the 1977 or 1980 season and would have first been eligible to appear on the Hall of Fame ballot in '83 or '86.  McCovey and Stargell both made it into the Hall of Fame on their first try, with McCovey picking up 81.4% of the vote on the '86 ballot and Stargell collecting 82.4% on the '88 ballot.  Williams didn't have quite as easy a road, making his debut on a very crowded '82 ballot that included fellow first time nominees Hank Aaron and Frank Robinson.  Aaron and Robinson were easily elected with 97.8% and 89.2% of the vote, while Williams drew just 23.4%.  The following year, Williams' support jumped to 40.9% and continued to rise, about 10% a year, until he was voted in on his sixth ballot in 1987 with 85.7% of the vote.

Based on Baseball Reference's Neutralizer link, McGriff's career numbers translated into the "Second Deadball Era" would have been just a tick below McCovey and Stargell's but right on par with or slightly better than Williams'.  One drawback of the Neutralizer link is that it does seem to understate the effects of the "Second Deadball Era" on McGriff's home run totals.  Though, I think we can safely assume that had McGriff played during the "Second Deadball Era" at McCovey or Stargell's home ballparks, he would have hit around 450 or 475 homers with a batting average in the low to mid .270s, and probably been elected to the Hall of Fame somewhere around his fifth or sixth ballot.  And, had McGriff, like Williams, spent most of his home games aiming for the stands above the ivy covered brick walls of Wrigley, he likely would have hit just under 500 longballs with a batting average around .280, and rather easily been voted into Cooperstown--possibly on his first ballot.  Unfortunately, McGriff spent his career playing alongside the PED users of the Steroid Era who made a mockery of the home run and now has the misfortune of being overshadowed by those same PED users on the Hall of Fame ballot.

----by John Tuberty

Sources:  Baseball Reference, Baseball Reference Play Index, Baseball Almanac

Related Articles:  Jeff Bagwell, Fred McGriff, The Hall of Fame, and 400 Home Runs

Fred McGriff, The Hall of Fame and The High Road In The Steroid Era